CTN PRESS

CTN PRESS

NEWS & BLOGS EXCLUCIVELY FOR INFORMATION TO ENGINEERS & VALUERS COMMUNITY

MEANING AND USE OF THE LEGAL TERMS: OBITER

MEANING AND USE OF THE LEGAL TERMS: OBITER

Meaning and Use of the Legal Term: Obiter

Definition: Obiter dictum, commonly referred to as “obiter,” is a Latin legal term that translates to “said in passing.” It represents remarks or comments made by a judge during a court case that are not directly relevant to the final decision or the essential reasoning behind the judgment. These statements are not binding as legal precedent but may offer persuasive value in future cases.

Use and Significance:

  • Persuasive Value: While not forming the binding part of the decision (ratio decidendi), obiter dicta can carry persuasive weight in similar or future cases. Legal professionals might consider these remarks when arguing a case, but they are not legally obligatory.
  • Clarification and Guidance: Obiter statements often provide insights into the judge’s thought process, legal reasoning, or interpretation of the law. They can clarify aspects of the law that weren’t central to the case but are still relevant.
  • Caution in Application: Despite their influence, obiter dicta are not legally binding. Judges should exercise caution in relying solely on these remarks when determining the outcome of a case.
  • Understanding Precedent: Distinguishing between obiter and the ratio decidendi is crucial in understanding legal precedent. The latter refers to the legal principle forming the basis for the court’s decision and sets the precedent for future cases.

Example: In a hypothetical case involving a contract dispute where the main issue concerned the method of acceptance, the judge might offer a comment on the potential consequences of a different clause in similar contracts. Although not essential to the resolution of the present case, this comment would be considered an obiter dictum and could provide valuable insights for future cases involving similar contractual language.

Conclusion: Obiter dicta play a nuanced role in legal proceedings. While they lack the binding force of the ratio decidendi, they contribute to legal discourse by providing context, guidance, and potential insights into judicial reasoning, aiding the development of the

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top